| # | Title | Artist |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mary, Did You Know? | Lowry, Mark |
| 2 | Noel | Chris Tomlin ft. Lauren Daigle |
| 3 | Breath of Heaven (Mary's Song) | Grant, Amy |
| 4 | Beautiful Star of Bethlehem | Bill & Gloria Gaither |
| 5 | Mary, Did You Know? | Mattea, Kathy |
| 6 | Breath of Heaven | Grant, Amy |
| 7 | Mary, Did You Know? | Mattea, Kathy |
| 8 | Mary, Did You Know? [Low Voice] | Lowry, Mark |
| 9 | Breath of Heaven | Grant, Amy |
| 10 | All Is Well | Smith, Michael W. |
| 11 | Light of the World | Daigle, Lauren |
| 12 | Sweet Little Jesus Boy | MacGimsey, Robert |
| 13 | Joseph's Lullaby | MercyMe |
| 14 | Light of the World | Daigle, Lauren |
| 15 | Welcome To Our World | Rice, Chris |
| 16 | Happy Birthday, Jesus | The Brooklyn Tabernacle Choir |
| 17 | Joseph's Song | Card, Michael |
| 18 | Night of Silence | Kantor, Daniel |
| 19 | Breath of Heaven (Mary's Song) | Grant, Amy |
| 20 | Do You Hear What I Hear? | Underwood, Carrie |
| 21 | Holy Forever | Tomlin, Chris |
| 22 | Goodness of God | Winans, Cece |
| 23 | Mary, Did You Know? | Hayes, Mark |
| 24 | Joy to the World (Unspeakable Joy) | Tomlin, Chris |
| 25 | Mary, Did You Know? | Rogers, Kenny |
| 26 | Mary, Did You Know? | Lowry, Mark |
| 27 | Breath of Heaven | Grant, Amy |
| 28 | Because of Bethlehem | West, Matthew |
| 29 | All Is Well | Point of Grace |
| 30 | Child of the Poor / What Child Is This | Soper, Scott |
| 31 | Adore | Tomlin, Chris |
| 32 | Noel | Chris Tomlin ft. Lauren Daigle |
| 33 | Messiah | Battistelli, Francesca |
| 34 | Come Jesus Come | Winans, Cece |
| 35 | Grown-Up Christmas List | Grant, Amy |
| 36 | Manger Throne | Wickham, Phil |
| 37 | I Heard the Bells on Christmas Day | Casting Crowns |
| 38 | O Come, O Come, Emmanuel | Battistelli, Francesca |
| 39 | Somewhere in Your Silent Night | Casting Crowns |
| 40 | Mary, Did You Know? | English, Michael |
| 41 | How Many Kings | Downhere |
| 42 | Make Room | Casting Crowns feat. Matt Maher |
| 43 | Gratitude | Lake, Brandon |
| 44 | Holy Forever - CeCe Winans | Winans, Cece |
| 45 | Goodness of God | Bethel Music |
| 46 | In the Bleak Midwinter | Holst, Gustav |
| 47 | King of Kings | Hillsong Worship |
| 48 | Amazing Grace (My Chains Are Gone) | Tomlin, Chris |
| 49 | Here With Us | Williams, Joy |
| 50 | Noel - Lauren Daigle | Signature Score |